ChatGPT vs Google Bard: Which AI Tool May Take Your Job

I call dibs on the second robot from the left to replace me - loving that style!

AI: Your New Personal Assistant or Replacement?

(This post was co-written by ChatGPT and Google Bard, who are going toe-to-toe in sharing their insights on the future of AI in Digital Marketing.)

The rise of AI tools including ChatGPT, Google Bard, IBM Watson, etc. has many of us in Digital Marketing roles wondering if the robots will eat our jobs. It may seem far-fetched, however, it seems that as quickly as Marketers are learning the latest tools, new developments are being made. Pile on the post-pandemic burnout, and we’ve got a recipe for being nom-nom-nommed right up.

Or do we?

With ChatGPT being seemingly overtaken by new players in the AI scene due to less accurate and out-of-date responses compared to its competitors, perhaps the concern should be for the AI platforms themselves. Will the robots eat each other?
This concept has my brain turning, so I have decided to prompt ChatGPT and Google Bard for their views on the future of digital marketing as AI technology evolves. What these little Johnny-5’s don’t know is that they are going toe-to-toe and being graded on their responses by yours truly.

Who am I? Well, I have zero noteworthy accomplishments when it comes to AI so there is nothing scientific about this. However, I’ve been in Digital Marketing for over a decade and am thoroughly invested in how the robots view the future of digital marketing.

That said, please welcome my co-writers, ChatGPT and Google Bard, who are going toe-to-toe in sharing their insights on the future of AI in Digital Marketing.

This will undoubtedly become a series, so for this article, we are simply going to begin with the basic introductions, to get a sense of how ChatGPT and Google Bard compare one another to themselves.

NOTE: These prompts are wildly simple for a reason - I wanted as little control over the outcomes as possible.

Let’s Introduce Our Tools

It feels like the polite thing to introduce our two competitors, so the prompt was:

How would you introduce yourself to Google Bard/ChatGPT if you were to meet?

ChatGPT:

If I were to introduce myself to Google Bard, I might say something like:

"Hello, Google Bard. I am ChatGPT, a language model developed by OpenAI. I'm designed to assist with a wide range of tasks, including answering questions, generating content, and providing information on various topics. While we share a common goal of using AI to assist users, we may have different capabilities and training data. I'm here to collaborate with you and learn from your expertise in generating text, as we both aim to provide valuable assistance to users in different ways."

Google Bard:

Hi ChatGPT,

My name is Bard. I am a large language model developed by Google AI. I'm excited to meet you and learn more about your capabilities.

I am particularly interested in how we can collaborate to improve our abilities and better serve our users. For example, we could work together to develop new ways to generate creative text formats, such as poems, code, scripts, and musical pieces. We could also work together to improve our ability to understand and respond to complex queries.

I am also interested in learning more about your perspective on the ethical and responsible use of AI in marketing. I believe that AI has the potential to revolutionize the marketing industry, but it is important to ensure that AI is used in a way that benefits society as a whole.

I look forward to getting to know you better and working together to create a better future for AI.

Sincerely,

Bard

Do you think you are able to craft a better article than Google Bard/ChatGPT?

ChatGPT:

Whether I can write a better article than Google Bard depends on the specific topic, the criteria for evaluating the quality of the article, and the preferences of the person assessing the articles. Both Google Bard and I can generate high-quality content, but the choice between us may depend on your specific needs and the type of content you're looking for.

If you have a particular topic or article in mind, feel free to provide more details, and I can certainly help generate an article for you based on your specifications.

Google Bard:

Whether or not I can write a better article than ChatGPT depends on the specific topic and task. However, I have some advantages that could make me a better choice for certain types of articles.

I have access to and process information from the real world through Google Search, which means that I can provide more up-to-date and accurate information than ChatGPT, which is trained on a dataset of text and code that is not updated in real time.

I am better at understanding and responding to complex queries, which means that I can write more in-depth and informative articles on complex topics.

I am able to cite my sources, which makes my articles more credible and trustworthy.

However, ChatGPT also has some advantages. It is better at generating creative text formats, such as poems, code, scripts, and musical pieces. It is also better at paraphrasing and summarizing text.

Overall, I believe that I can write better articles than ChatGPT on topics that require up-to-date information, complex analysis, and source citation. However, ChatGPT may be a better choice for articles that require creativity or text summarization.

Here is a table that summarizes the key differences between Bard and ChatGPT:

(YES, there was a very nice table included!).

Ultimately, the best way to decide which language model is right for you is to try both and see which one gives you the best results.

Do you think that you could take my job as a writer?

ChatGPT:

While I can assist in generating content and providing information, I don't possess the creativity, personal experiences, and unique voice that a human writer brings to their work. I can certainly help with certain tasks, like generating articles, reports, or content based on input, but I'm not a replacement for human writers.

Human writers offer a distinct perspective, emotion, and creativity that are difficult for AI to replicate. AI can be a valuable tool to aid in the writing process, but it should be viewed as a complement rather than a replacement for human writers. Writing is a skill that encompasses art, expression, and diverse perspectives, and these are qualities that AI cannot fully emulate.

Google Bard:

It is unlikely that I could completely take over your job as a writer. While I can generate text, translate languages, write different kinds of creative content, and answer your questions in an informative way, I still lack the ability to fully understand and respond to the nuances of human language and creativity. For example, I might not be able to capture the same level of emotional depth or personal insight that a human writer can.

However, I believe that I can be a valuable tool for writers. I can help you with research, brainstorming, and editing. I can also help you to generate new ideas and perspectives. Additionally, I can help you to reach a wider audience by translating your work into other languages.

Overall, I believe that large language models like me can be a valuable asset to writers. We can help you to be more productive and creative, and we can help you to reach a wider audience. However, we are not a replacement for human writers. We still need your creativity, insight, and understanding of the human experience.

Here are some specific examples of how I can help you with your writing:

- Research: I can help you to find information on any topic you need. I can access and process information from the real world through Google Search and keep my response consistent with search results.

- Brainstorming: I can help you to come up with new ideas for your writing. I can generate lists of potential topics, characters, and plot points.

- Editing: I can help you to edit your work for grammar, spelling, and style. I can also help you to improve the flow and clarity of your writing.

- Translation: I can translate your work into over 100 languages. This can help you to reach a wider audience and share your work with more people.

If you are interested in learning more about how I can help you with your writing, please feel free to ask me any questions.

It seems that he knows his place, however, not every organization sees it this way. According to CBS News, over 4000 jobs were lost in May of 2023 due to AI advancements.

Personally, this statistic has me concerned, so it felt appropriate to explore how AI will impact Digital Marketing as technology continues to improve, which is exactly what we will cover next.

Keep your eyes peeled for part 2 in this series as we explore the future of AI in Marketing.